2025 Bay Street Theater Holiday Auction logo

6th ANNUAL  HOLIDAY SILENT AUCTION

Celebrating 34 years of theatrical excellence.

2025 Bay Street Theater Holiday Auction background

BAY STREET THEATER  HOLIDAY SILENT AUCTION

Auction will close Sunday, December 7 at NOON.


 WELCOME AND HAPPY HOLIDAYS!

We know you'll enjoy the many experiences and great gifts made available to you this year through our generous sponsors and artists. We're positive you’ll find something for everyone on your holiday list. 

Besides the great gifts you'll find in our auction below, here are some other great gift ideas for friends and family—especially those folks who seem so hard to buy for.

How about…

*A Subscription to our 2026 Mainstage summer season!  

*Winter or Summer Vacation Camps and classes for kids.

*Gift certificates of any size!   

On behalf of all of us at Bay Street Theater, we thank YOU for allowing us to share so many stories that need to be told. In the words of Terrance McNally's Master Class, "I think that we have made this world a better place. That we have left it richer, wiser than had we not chosen the way of art."  

To our audience, to the ushers, to the performers, crew and employees, we wish you and your family a very joyous, healthy and safe holiday season.  

With gratitude always,                

Tracy Mitchell & Scott Schwartz                                                                    

Executive Director & Artistic Director


                                                                                     

FREQUENTLY-ASKED QUESTIONS:

Q:  How do I start bidding/ register?
A:  If you already have an account, click the "Register" button above and type your email address or phone number. Enter the code to verify your device. You may be prompted to complete your account with additional information. This will take you right to the bidding page.

Q:  What if I don't have an account yet?
A:  Click "Register" above.  Enter your contact info and credit card, and you will be taken right to the bidding page.

Q:  What if I want to bid without registering?
A:  Sorry, you can't.  We need to know who is bidding, so you must be registered with your credit card before bidding is allowed.

Q:  How do I collect the item if I win?
A:  Someone from Bay Street's staff will contact you with details.

Q:  I think something's not working right.  Who can help me out?
A: Email us at ejacobson@baystreet.org.

Just a few of our items...

Auction Items (151)

See All Items
Item image
Item image
#1

TWP Sag Harbor / Cashmere Sweater

$500 Current Bid
3 Bids
Item image
Item image
#2

Quackenbush Cesspools

$850 Current Bid
7 Bids
Item image
Item image
#80

WEEK LONG Luxury Villa for TWO @ WIMCO Villas!

Value: Priceless TRAVEL
$5,750 Current Bid
10 Bids
Item image
Item image
#81

Viking River Cruise for 2; 8 Day, 7 Night!

Value: Priceless TRAVEL
$6,500 Current Bid
7 Bids
Item image
Item image
#82

Script Review with Director Scott Schwartz

Value: Priceless
$750 Current Bid
2 Bids
$2,500 Buy It Now
Item image
Item image
#84

Gardiner's Bay CC, Shelter Island- Golf Foursome

Value: Priceless
$2,600 Current Bid
7 Bids
Item image
Item image
#85

American Hotel: Dinner for 8 + 8 Mainstage Tickets!

Value: Priceless EXPERIENCES
$2,575 Current Bid
18 Bids
Item image
Item image
#86

Golf for TWO @ The Bridge with Actor Richard Kind!

Value: Priceless SPORTS & LEISURE
$3,500 Current Bid
10 Bids
Item image
Item image
#87

Wolffer Private Wine Cellar Tour and Tasting for 8

Value: Priceless EXPERIENCES
$1,100 Current Bid
4 Bids
Item image
Item image
#90

Sunset Sail during High Season 2026!

EXPERIENCES
$1,400 Current Bid
3 Bids

It all has to go!

Buy Now! Limited Stock.

Tiffany's "Toile" Bone China Jam Bowl! 

Take a chance!

RAFFLE! A Chance to Win the Bay Street Theater Red Carpet Experience!

Help us reach our goal!

Bay Street Theater builds community. Every dime helps supports our mission in keeping theater alive.

Know where your money is going...

TAKE A BOW!

OUR SPONSORS

A heartfelt thank you to all our sponsors! Your ongoing support for Bay Street Theater means the world to us, especially during these challenging times. We couldn't be prouder to be part of such a wonderful community.

Content block image

Thank you for your support

RULES & REGULATIONS

1. Eligibility

  • All bidders must be at least 18 years old.
  • By placing a bid, participants agree to all rules and regulations listed below.

2. Bidding

  • All bids are final and binding.
  • No bid retractions are allowed once submitted.
  • The auction closing time is final; any bids submitted after the deadline will not be accepted.

3. Winning Bids

  • The highest valid bid at the close of the auction will be declared the winner.
  • Winners will be notified via email or through the auction platform.
  • Winners must confirm acceptance and arrange payment within 48 hours of notification (or your preferred timeframe).

4. Payment

  • All payments must be completed in full before items are released.
  • Accepted payment methods will be detailed by the auction organizer (e.g., credit card, PayPal, cash, etc.).
  • Admin Fees/ Credit Card Fees will be covered by the winners. 

5. Item Pickup & Shipping

  • All winning items must be picked up no later than Monday, September 7, 2026 (Labor Day).
  • Pickup location and hours will be provided to winners.
  • If the winner cannot pick up their item in person, they may request shipping if the item is eligible.
  • For any items requiring mailing, all postage, packaging, and shipping costs must be paid by the winner in advance.
  • The auction organizer is not responsible for any loss or damage that occurs during shipping.

6. Forfeiture

  • Failure to complete payment or pick up an item by the deadline may result in forfeiture of the item, with no refund. The expiration of all items is LABOR DAY 2026.
  • The organizer may offer the item to the next highest bidder or re-list it at their discretion.

7. Item Condition & Descriptions

  • All items are offered “as-is” with no warranties, unless otherwise noted.
  • Every effort has been made to provide accurate descriptions and photos, but slight variations may occur.

8. Disputes

  • Any disputes will be resolved at the sole discretion of the auction organizers.
  • The organizer's decision is final.

9. Privacy

  • Bidder information will be used only for auction-related communication and will not be shared with third parties, except as required to process payment or delivery.

10. Agreement

  • By participating in this auction, bidders acknowledge and agree to all the rules and regulations listed above.